Chipotle, the fast-casual restaurant chain specializing in Mexican food, has launched a new loyalty program called Chipotle Rewards. The company is currently beta testing the program in three markets: Phoenix, AZ; Kansas City, MO/KS; and Columbus, OH, and plans to roll out nationwide in 2019. For this week’s blog, I thought it would be fun to do a professional review of the new program using the five criteria for assessing loyalty program value I wrote about previously.
First, a few details about Chipotle Rewards. The program is free to join. Members earn 10 points per $1 spent at its restaurants or through catering orders, and 15 points per $1 for orders placed via its website or mobile app. There will be bonus actions consumers can complete to earn additional points. Once a member accumulates 1250 points, those points can be redeemed for a free regular-priced entrée item. Rewards expire after 60 days. Till Nov. 21, 2018, the program is offering a joining incentive of a free order of Chips & Guac after the new member makes the first purchase under the program. Let’s take a look at how this design stacks up against the five value criteria.
Criterion #1: Cash Value
In my geographic area, a typical entrée on the Chipotle menu costs about $7~$8. Together with the point earning ratio of 10 points per $1 and a reward threshold of 1250 points, we can calculate the reward ratio to be ($7~$8/1250)*10 = $0.056~$0.064 per dollar spent (or 5.6%~6.4%). This reward ratio is pretty high compared with a typical credit card reward program, but how does it compare with other restaurant loyalty programs? Chipotle’s direct competitor, QDOBA, also runs a loyalty program called QDOBA Rewards. The program requires 3000 points for a free entrée priced at the $8 range, with lower thresholds for cheaper items. The earning ratio for QDOBA Rewards is the same 10 points per $1 at the two lower tiers (Recruit and Apprentice), and goes up to 15 points per $1 for the Pro tier and 20 points per $1 for the highest Champ tier. Putting these numbers together, it appears QDOBA Rewards has a base reward ratio of about 2.67% for the two lower tiers, and 4% and 5.33% for the two higher tiers. Comparatively speaking, Chipotle Rewards offers a higher cash value. However, considering the bonus points per visit offered to higher-tier members of QDOBA Rewards, the two programs are more comparable in cash value at the higher tiers. Continue reading “Loyalty Program Review: Chipotle Rewards”