How to Lose Loyalty in 10 Days: Lessons from the Facebook Fiasco

This month marks my first Facebook-less month. Like more than 35,000 other users who have signed up to do so, I closed my Facebook account on May 31. For someone like me who rarely participates in movements of any kind, Facebook has elicited in me an usually intense negative feeling. This has not always been the case, however. I had started as an early adopter of Facebook, partially due to the privilege of having a .edu email address as a university professor. In those early days, I was an avid advocator of Facebook and marveled at the revolution it would bring to the social landscape. What happened then? In a few years, I had turned from a Facebook lover to a Facebook hater. Reflecting on my own journey, I realized that there are important loyalty lessons here for businesses to learn.

Quit Facebook Day

Don’t Forget Your Roots

Like many media companies, one unique aspect of the Facebook business model is that the end users of Facebook are not the same people who pay the bills for Facebook. Facebook started as a social network intended to connect people and eventually grew into a business model deriving revenues from advertisers. Nobody blames Facebook for wanting to make money. After all, it is a business and it has to make money to survive. What Facebook did wrong, however, was to make every business decision based on money AND at the cost of its roots, the millions of end users. Continue reading “How to Lose Loyalty in 10 Days: Lessons from the Facebook Fiasco”

Segment Your Brand Community Participants Part 3

I created this series to help brand community managers to identify and focus their efforts based on the types of participants in their communities. In this last part of the series, I would like to offer some suggestions on what to do with each of the four segments (insiders, minglers, devotees, and tourists) once you have identified them.

 

 

Most likely, you will find all four types of participants in your community. However, depending on the developmental stage and the health of your community, the percentage of participants that fall into each segment may vary. The table below lists the suggested goals and engagement strategies for each of the segments. If your resource is limited, I suggest you go with the insiders first, as these participants are great partners and can turn your army of one into thousands at a low cost.

Continue reading “Segment Your Brand Community Participants Part 3”

Are Your Customers Really Loyal?

 

If Jane comes to your store every Saturday and spends $50, would you consider Jane a loyal customer? Driven by concerns about the bottom line, businesses often define loyalty based on how much consumers spend and how often they buy. But digging a little deeper into the psychological reasons behind “loyalty” can reveal important insight and help identify effective target marketing strategies.

In Jane’s situation, there are two possible reasons behind her “loyal” patronage: (1) she genuinely likes your products and services, and therefore, when need arises, she always comes to your store to make a purchase; (2) she comes to your store out of habit, whenever she’s on her way to visit her grandma on Saturdays. In other words, both habit and true loyalty can drive Jane’s seemingly loyal behavior, and your optimal marketing strategy should be different based on the exact reason involved. Let’s dissect this a little further, shall we?

Continue reading “Are Your Customers Really Loyal?”