Category: Reality Check

Social Media Lessons from Thirty Brands

Posted on

Last semester, my Internet marketing students completed a social media project. They were asked to follow three social media channels by a company of their choice, and then write up their experience about it. Together, we observed 30+ companies’ social media practices, ranging from lesser-known brands to major players in the social media arena such as Starbucks and Best Buy. In this blog, I would like to share some qualitative conclusions from those observations.

Twitter Chirp

Photo by Flickr User Widjaya Ivan | CC 2.0

What Works

Polls and questions: Asking consumers easy questions that are tangentially related to the product seems to receive good reactions from consumers, and many do respond. A key to this practice is to time the questions based on what’s on consumers’ mind at the moment (e.g., holiday, economy, etc.).

Contests and submissions: It may seem like a lot of companies are running contests nowadays. But in our observation, it still seems to work quite well among consumers. Visibility of winning is important. An example is ESPN’s use of fan-submitted photos as its profile picture. This is updated every week so that the chance of winning is pretty frequent.
Continue reading “Social Media Lessons from Thirty Brands”

When Your Business Talks Too Much

Posted on

Lured by Cyber Monday deals, I bought something from ToysRUs.com for the first time this past weekend. Besides the order confirmation email, I received six additional promotional emails from the company, in just three day. That averages about two a day. Annoying? Sure! But ToysRUs is not alone. In the last one to two years, I have seen major retailers dramatically increase their email promotion frequency. Just a few weeks ago, I had removed myself from the email lists of well-known retailers such as New York & Company, Victoria’s Secret, to name just a few. Some of these companies were sending me daily if not more email messages about something on sale. It appears that either the recent economic recession has turned these retailers desperate, or a new marketing bible is out there somewhere teaching these retailers to bombard consumers with emails.

Is this strategy effective? Business aside, let me ask you this: have you ever met someone who can talk your head off and don’t know when or how to shut up? If you can’t picture that, think about Adrian Monk’s upstairs neighbor in the hit TV show Monk. What do we do when we meet people like that? We usually try to avoid them like the plague. I did with those retailers. When I asked my students what they do, they said they simply deleted the emails. I am sure this is not what the retailers intended.

Cover Ears
Photo by Flickr user oddharmonic | CC2.0

Now, I am not discounting the effectiveness of email marketing. When used appropriately, emails can be an effective and low-cost way of communicating with customers and keeping a business in consumers’ mind. But just like most things in this world, too much is not a good thing. Let me present a few reasons why daily or too frequent promotional emails are neither necessary nor effective: Continue reading “When Your Business Talks Too Much”

Best Practices — Old Spice Marketing Campaign

Posted on

This year is a good year for Old Spice. Starting with the “Smell Like a Man, Man campaign” followed by the successful Old Spice Man viral videos, the once quiet brand is now stirring up plenty of buzz among marketers and consumers alike. When I went to the Society for New Communications Research 5th Research Symposium earlier this month, I attended a session where Old Spice brand manager James Moorhead told the stories behind the recent marketing success. In this blog, I’d like to share some of what I learned with you.

Campaign Summary

The Old Spice marketing campaign is called “Smell Like a Man, Man”. So far, the campaign has gone through three phases:

Phase 1: Launched around the Superbowl time, it uses humorous vignettes featuring a sexy man to convey the brand’s role in the journey from a young man to full manhood. During that same time period, Dove was planning to launch a competing new men’s personal care product line Dove Men+Care on Superbowl. But Old Spice decided to launch its campaign “around” Superbowl rather than on Superbowl for cost efficiency and proper audience reach (more on that later). Below is a commercial from this phase.

Continue reading “Best Practices — Old Spice Marketing Campaign”