A student of mine shared this article on CNN.com with me: “Can second Life Help Teach Doctors to Treat Patients?” It is an interesting illustration of the potential best use of Second Life, at least in the short-term. While the original idea of Second Life was to create a virtual world where individuals can take on the role of an alter ego, the true business appeal of Second Life really lies in its capability to bring computer objects to life. Within the 3D environment, individuals can reenact real-world scenarios in a semi-real setting, a departure from the 2D dominated Internet. Thus, what is most useful about Second Life is not really the hundreds of thousands of users in the network, in contrary to other social networks such as Facebook. Rather, it is the ability to simulate real-world scenarios that may be difficult or expensive to take place in reality. Such applications include product development and demonstration; customer collaboration; teleconferencing; education and other types of simulation; and team work across geographic areas. While businesses have entered Second Life a few years ago to build a “presence” in Second Life for marketing purposes, I envision continued use of Second Life to focus more in these other business areas and applications.
Category: Reality Check
Understanding Chinese Consumers
I left China to go to graduate school in the US when I was 22, right at the time when I should have become a mainstream Chinese consumer. Instead, I became re-socialized (or “acculturated” in academic terminology) into an American consumer. Recently I was able to make a nearly month-long trip to China. With some distance now established from my home culture, I was able to observe with a fresh pair of eyes the unique characteristics of Chinese consumers and to reacquaint myself with values and behaviors that I had taken for granted before I left China 11 years ago. In this blog, I discuss three things that I observed about Chinese consumer behavior during my trip.
1. Chinese consumers are highly brand conscious. The shopping malls I visited in China were dominated by boutique stores from famous (a.k.a. expensive) designer labels such as Burberry, Salvatore Ferragamo, and Chanel. Perhaps more surprisingly, these stores were brimming with shoppers who were actually buying. Yes, having such a high concentration of luxury stores is a ready manifestation of the higher income level in a more developed China. But with most consumers’ monthly income still only enough to buy, say, two $200 Burberry shirts, the popularity of these luxury brands reveals the brand-consciousness among Chinese consumers. Even for less expensive purchases such as milk, snacks, and liquor, well-known brand names disproportionately dominate the market. Why are Chinese consumers so brand conscious? I infer that it has to do with the inconsistent quality of products sold in China. As a newly developed market economy, China has not yet established a sound market self-regulation mechanism. Consequently, consumers do not yet trust vendors in the marketplace. The mistrust goes the other way too, as most stores carry a no-return policy, increasing the risks associated with each purchase. The outcome? Chinese consumers flock to established brand names to reduce risk and protect their own welfare.
2. Consumer trends travel fast in China. Being in a collectivistic culture, Chinese consumers tend to have closer interactions with each other than people from a more individualistic culture such as America. People talk to each other more often and are more likely to have closer or even overlapping personal spaces. Adding the lack of confidence in vendors, word of mouth becomes extremely powerful in consumers’ purchase decisions. Once a new trend is initiated, it tends to travel very fast across the population. You may find, for example, many households to become equipped with soy milk machines over the course of a short period of time. Another helping factor is the unique media landscape. Although TV channels have proliferated in China in the last twenty years, the CCTV channels are still the dominant provider of national and international news. With their high viewership, these channels are able to exert an unduly influence on consumer opinions and offer advertisers a way to reach a big mass of consumers (imagine Superbowl every day).
3. Consumption in China is public. It is well-known that Asian cultures put more emphasis on education. But I experienced a more “public” version of this value. In a discussion among friends about sending their toddlers to kindergartens and schools, I overheard parents reluctantly acknowledge a pressure to send their kids to the best of schools, even if these schools come with an astronomical price tag that they can barely afford. Their arguments were that they want to give their kids the best start, but even more importantly, not to look like they are being cheap on their kids in front of their colleagues and friends. This “publicity of consumption” is further fueled by the collectivistic culture, through a higher level of willingness to meddle in someone else’s business (i.e., people will talk, even in front of you) and through a higher pressure to conform to the norm.
I should conclude this blog with a footnote that these are only my short-term observations and undoubtedly carry with them my own individual bias and the special environment of the two metropolitan cities that I visited (Hong Kong and Shenzhen). So they are only intended to stimulate the thinking of those who might be interested in marketing to Chinese consumers rather than function as golden rules of Chinese consumer behavior.
Best Practices — P&G Mr. Clean Car Wash
What is it?
You might be aware of the Mr. Clean AutoDry Carwash System. Well, Mr. Clean Car Wash I am talking about here is not a product. It is an actual car wash service that P&G opened up in Ohio. Two locations have been opened so far, one in Mason and the other in Cincinnati. Besides this innovative brand extension, it has also been reported that P&G is opening up Tide-Y dry cleaners in the Kansas City area.
Why is it a good idea?
(1) Household products are a highly-saturated market. Branching out from the product market to services opens up a whole new set of opportunities and revenue potentials. As an added bonus, the services area is also highly fragmented competition-wise, unlike the product market.
(2) A physical shop gives P&G an opportunity to put a face to its products. Managed well, this can lead to more intimate and meaningful customer relationships.
(3) The shops can serve the function of advertising and publicity for the physical product/brand.
(4) Having first-experience with people’s carwashing and dry-cleaning behavior can give P&G valuable market research information.
Small Print
Sometimes an idea is so pioneering and unusual that it naturally comes with some risks. For P&G, the biggest risk is in its ability to execute these service shops well. Being a consumer packaged goods company, it is not exactly an expert on services marketing and service logistics. If not done right, bad customer experience from the physical shops can have a damaging effect on the core brand. I suspect this is partially the reason why P&G has been very cautious in this area, so far keeping a very low key, only experimenting with the idea in selected local areas and possibly rolling out nationally if the experiments prove successful.